Back to previous page

Should I Fight a Traffic Ticket?

If you have received a traffic ticket that you feel you did not deserve, you may wonder whether it is worth your time to go to court or if you should simply pay the fine. Traffic violations are difficult to fight. For this reason, many people who receive traffic tickets do not bother to go to court, even though they believe a court appearance might clear their record of the violation for which they have been cited. You will have to decide for yourself whether you want to take the time to fight a ticket. However, if you are concerned about your driving record and protecting your automobile insurance, or if there are unusual circumstances––for instance, if you have been given a speeding ticket while rushing someone to the hospital––you should think over your decision carefully.

People normally associate traffic tickets with the ordinance violations heard in municipal, or city court. However, motor vehicle offenses also include crimes for which you can be arrested, and are actually divided into three categories: City ordinance violations, misdemeanors, and felonies. Traffic tickets are always issued in lieu of an arrest for municipal ordinance violations, sometimes issued for misdemeanor offenses, and never issued for felony offenses.

A city ordinance violation––for example speeding or failure to stop at a stop sign––is punishable by a fine only but no imprisonment. Drivers charged with a violation are not placed under arrest, but instead are given a ticket which serves as a summons to court. A driver who receives a ticket has the option of mailing payment of costs and a fine to the court in lieu of a personal appearance, or appearing in court on the designated date to contest the charge or plead guilty to the violation. There may be a hearing before the judge, but no jury trial. Cases are heard in the municipal court for the city or town where the violation occurred.

By contrast, a misdemeanor traffic offense is punishable by a fine and up to 11 months and 29 days in a county workhouse. There will be a jury trial unless it is waived––that is, unless you and the prosecutor do not want a jury to hear the case and are willing to let a judge decide the case. A felony traffic violation––vehicular homicide, for instance––is punishable by a minimum term of one (1) year in state prison. There will be a jury trial unless you and the prosecutor choose to waive it.

Except for city ordinance violations, a person who is charged with a traffic offense has the same rights as any accused person. You are entitled to be represented by an attorney if you like and an attorney may be appointed by the court for those who cannot afford one. In fact, if you are charged with a misdemeanor or felony, you should seriously consider consulting with a lawyer. As to city ordinance violations, you have no right to a jury trial or a court-appointed attorney because there is no possibility of your going to jail or prison. You may, however, seek to have an attorney represent you for an ordinance violation.

If you cannot afford an attorney, but you still feel that you are innocent of the act of the traffic violation or that there are unusual circumstances in your case, by all means insist on a trial of your case and insist that the prosecutor prove your guilt. Before you go to court, prepare your case. Check the law you are accused of violating to make certain you understand it. If pictures will help your case, bring them to court. Bring any witnesses, especially people who were in the car with you at the time of the alleged violation.

Make your defense in as clear and simple terms as possible. Avoid legal terms that you do not understand. Just tell your own story the way you see it. The Court is usually very helpful to people without lawyers. Tell the truth and present your case as carefully as you can.